The Nottingham Tavern Menu (Update 2025)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to The Nottingham Tavern, a cherished corner bar located in Hamilton Square, NJ. This historic establishment has evolved from its 18th-century roots into a vibrant culinary hub, serving a diverse array of delicious dishes.

The menu highlights include:

  • Bar Pie - Perfect for pizza enthusiasts.
  • Starters - Indulge in their renowned disco fries, chicken fingers, and savory cheesesteak eggrolls.
  • Salads - Fresh options like arugula and Caesar await health-conscious diners.

Customer reviews emphasize the friendly bartenders, a lively atmosphere, and standout dishes such as the buffalo wings and cheesesteak eggrolls. Whether enjoying a live band or mingling with locals, The Nottingham Tavern promises a memorable experience filled with flavor and camaraderie. Come for the food, stay for the warm, inviting vibe!

Pizza Starters Salads Speciality Pies Sandwiches Panini

Pizza

Bar Pie

Tomato Pie

Brooklyn

Pickle Chips

Mozzarella Sticks

Disco Fries

Onion Rings

Cheesesteak Eggrolls

Chicken Fingers & Fries

Nachos

Loaded Nott Tots

Zucchini Sticks

Mac & Cheese

Bavarian Pretzel

Broccoli Bites

Seasoned Fries

Buffalo Cauliflower

Starters

Salads

Caesar

Arugula

Antipasto

Prosciutto Arugula And Fig

Margherita

Buffalo Chicken

Mustard Pie

Ricotta Pie With Sauteed Spinach

Meat Lovers

Drunken Brooklyn

Chicken Bacon Ranch

Veggie

Nutella

Speciality Pies

Sandwiches

Cheesesteak

Classic Burger

The Nott Burger

Italian Hot Dog

Chicken Cutlet

Roast Pork

Chicken Cheesesteak

Sausage Pepper & Onions

Caprese

Grilled Chicken

Grilled Cheese

Pork Belly

Buffalo Chicken

Italian Cuban

Panini